Downstairs Toilet Bubble Explosion, Floor Drain Overflows -No Apparent Clog in Plumbing or Vent Pipe

Users who are viewing this thread

RapaNui

New Member
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
Points
1
Location
Dexter, MI
Hi all,

This past Summer we purchased our first house, a split-level from the 1960's. With this purchase we had the sewer line inspected by camera and cleaned a couple months after we moved in. Since we've had the house, the basement toilet splashes when upstairs toilet is flushed. These toilets are more or less stacked on top of one another, with the vent pipe directly above the upstairs bathroom on the roof (one vent pipe in the house).

Recently we've been experiencing overflows from a nearby drain in the basement when we run a load of laundry through the washer. The overflow is the worst on the first washer empty. This drain is between the utility sink the washer empties into and the main sewer line out of the house. The largest overflow of the drain was from a single upstairs toilet flush after returning from 3 days of being away from the house; however, flushing the upstairs toilet doesn't usually cause an overflow. The basement toilet also bubbles sometimes when the upstairs shower is running, along with the sound of running water in the utility sink drain (likely vacated p-trap), and a slight overflow of the basement drain. This is infrequent, but does happen.

Attempted solutions. I ran a 15ft auger through basement plumbing lines, but couldn't get into the drain, so I called a professional. The plumber was able to snake between the drain that overflows and the main sewer line out of the house. So, everything should be clean in the pipes between the overflowing drain and where it exits the house. Since this didn't fix the problem, I did what he next recommended, installed a studor vent behind the utility sink. Still didn't help. Two days ago, I purchased a 50ft auger and ran it into the main vent on the roof, but it didn't hit anything. I flushed the vent with the hose, but the basement toilet is still splashing.

What's next? Are these multiple different problems? Is it just bad plumbing in the house? Or is there a clog somewhere?

Thanks so much!

 

RapaNui

New Member
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
Points
1
Location
Dexter, MI
Thanks for your reply! Would you recommend a second studor vent? Perhaps on the upstairs bathroom sink? Or would that not help...
 

RapaNui

New Member
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
Points
1
Location
Dexter, MI
Sounds like bad venting and back pitched lines and a slight blockage

Thanks Sylvan!

If you think it's a slight blockage, do you have any guesses where it would be? Downstream the basement toilet, but in upstream the floor drain? It's strange for me to think why the toilet/upstairs shower would have the ability to overflow the basement floor vent if that's where the blockage is.
 

Terry

The Plumbing Wizard
Staff member
Messages
29,942
Reaction score
3,462
Points
113
Location
Bothell, Washington
Website
terrylove.com
It's hard to say how yours might be plumbed. I've seen some flat venting below grade done in the past and if there is a backup, then there would be no venting there. It's rare, but I have seen at least one other home where the upstairs toilet would burp the downstairs bowl too. n any venting situation, you want the vent from the downstairs to tie in at 42" on the next floor.

dwv_b2.jpg
 

RapaNui

New Member
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
Points
1
Location
Dexter, MI
It's hard to say how yours might be plumbed. I've seen some flat venting below grade done in the past and if there is a backup, then there would be no venting there. It's rare, but I have seen at least one other home where the upstairs toilet would burp the downstairs bowl too. n any venting situation, you want the vent from the downstairs to tie in at 42" on the next floor.

dwv_b2.jpg

Thanks Terry! I really appreciate the diagram.

It would be nice to have a set of x-ray goggles or blueprints. I think what I'm going to try now is snake the toilet and see if that clears anything up. If it doesn't, I may call it quits and just live with it.
 

RapaNui

New Member
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
Points
1
Location
Dexter, MI
Hi all,

So I removed the toilet and snaked down the line with a 50ft 1/2" auger. No luck. A couple of weeks later our basement floor drain overflowed again when the shower was running upstairs.

I did add a second Studor to the back of the basement vanity <3ft from the bubbling toilet. No help there either.

I've called in a licensed plumber and he seems to have no idea. Of course, when he comes the plumbing is working 100% fine. We were planning on using a drain camera, but he offered to wait and see if I could do some tests to see where to go in at. He doesn't think the garbage disposal is the issue, but the next thing I've decided to try is to stop using it all together starting Feb. 28th.

I've been taking a journal of the daily happenings downstairs. The infuriating thing is the problem comes and goes.

February 27 -
While taking shower upstairs for 5-10 minutes, the basement toilet started bubbling, then the utility sink started bubbling. Then I left, upon return 5-10 minutes later, the floor drain had overflowed. Radius ~3 ft. After cleaning, I noticed the toilet had lost all water. The dishwasher was also running during shower. A second shower was taken downstairs after event. No problem.

February 28- No problems
February 29- No problems
March 1- No problems
March 2- No problems

March 3- While shower is running upstairs, I hear bubbling, went downstairs, single bubbles about one every second, but stopped after a minute. Nothing changed in utility sink. Water level still normal in toilet. Drain that usually overflows looked fine as well. Did a test flush upstairs right after shower, I checked downstairs during flush. There was some water movement, but no splash.

March 4-No problems

March 5- Single bubble/splash comes whenever the upstairs toilet is flushed. No bubbling when upstairs shower runs.
 

Jadnashua

Retired Defense Industry Engineer xxx
Messages
32,770
Reaction score
1,191
Points
113
Location
New England
With the right equipment and training, many cameras can determine what the slope of the drain line is. It sounds like your drain line doesn't have the proper slope. Lots of things, but if the pipe has a hole or bad joint, and the groundwater is high, it could be filling up with groundwater.

An AAV is a one-way air valve. It will only let air in, not out. So, if there's a clog, air can't get out properly as waste builds up, and your toilet could bubble as it pushes some air ahead of it. So, an AAV won't solve that.
 

Plumbs

In the Trades
Messages
106
Reaction score
48
Points
28
Location
Virginia
Have your plumber do the video inspection from the roof vent all the way to the main tap. Even better if you can do it right after it overflows downstairs. Don't run any water until the plumber shows up.
If there is a dip in the line or blocked vent that would show up with the video inspection.
 

RapaNui

New Member
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
Points
1
Location
Dexter, MI
I just want to thank everyone for their help. Had the cleanout access point inspected by camera this morning and it turns out there were roots in main drain line. The crazy thing was they were located in the middle of the house.

I'm optimistic removing them will solve the issue.

Cheers!
 

Sin

New Member
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Points
1
Location
Baltimore
How much did you pay for the problem… I’m having a issue with my pipes. I have four toilets in my 3 story home, when I use my shower or flush upstairs toilet water drains from bottom floor toilet where culking is which is barely there. When I wash clothes my utility sink fills up too. All I hear is gurgling noises. I bust a hole in my walls because I heard water dripping inside when my furnace drains… found a condensation line disconnected so I drilled a hole in an air pipe to drain to stop the leaking inside. Next few days I’m washing the utility sink backed up and the toilet next to it started pouring from floor and gurgling. I get a plumber to snake main line and he claims the snake is bending up by hitting something hard inside pipe. The plumber used a 75’ cable. Tomorrow he’s bringing a 1500 to see if this helps. Any suggestions ? I’m a female and all of this is literally making my head hurt. Makes me want to sell as is help!
 

Sylvan

Still learning
Messages
2,774
Reaction score
701
Points
113
Location
New York
How much did you pay for the problem… I’m having a issue with my pipes. I have four toilets in my 3 story home, when I use my shower or flush upstairs toilet water drains from bottom floor toilet where culking is which is barely there. When I wash clothes my utility sink fills up too. All I hear is gurgling noises. I bust a hole in my walls because I heard water dripping inside when my furnace drains… found a condensation line disconnected so I drilled a hole in an air pipe to drain to stop the leaking inside. Next few days I’m washing the utility sink backed up and the toilet next to it started pouring from floor and gurgling. I get a plumber to snake main line and he claims the snake is bending up by hitting something hard inside pipe. The plumber used a 75’ cable. Tomorrow he’s bringing a 1500 to see if this helps. Any suggestions ? I’m a female and all of this is literally making my head hurt. Makes me want to sell as is help!
It makes no difference what someone else paid as each company has to know their cost of doing business (TURN KEY) so their prices will be different from someone else

Also each stoppage is different . I have no idea why he /she would use a 1500 unless he /she expects a large amount of roots or needs to go over 100 feet
 
Top
Hey, wait a minute.

This is awkward, but...

It looks like you're using an ad blocker. We get it, but (1) terrylove.com can't live without ads, and (2) ad blockers can cause issues with videos and comments. If you'd like to support the site, please allow ads.

If any particular ad is your REASON for blocking ads, please let us know. We might be able to do something about it. Thanks.
I've Disabled AdBlock    No Thanks