Tilted toilet.. to replace or not replace.. that is the Question!!

Discussion in 'Toilet Forum discussions' started by pestario76, Mar 5, 2010.

  1. pestario76

    pestario76 New Member

    Mar 4, 2010
    Westville, Indiana
    Ok.. so I have this half bathroom (the dreadful color is unimportant!!) when you sit on the extrememly Cold toilet seat..(also not important!!, sorry) the toilet shifts and its not the seat its the entire toilet.. its tilted? or uneven? not a HUGE tilt persay.. but its definitally noticable. The tank sounds like it starts to refill when this happens .. for like a moment...then it stops. My question is.. is this fixable.. without replacing the floor? the floor doesnt appear saggy or sunk in.. or uneven.. I wasnt sure if there was something missing on the base of the toilet itself that I could replace or will I have to call a plumber? I am a very quick study and good with my hands.. ( the son my father never had!! jk) Also, if this is something that is fairly easily fixed.. what tools will I need to buy, borrow, or rent? I would Love to NOT call a plumber as I am fairly broke.. :)
  2. jadnashua

    jadnashua Retired Defense Industry Engineer xxx

    Sep 2, 2004
    Retired Systems engineer for defense industry.
    New England
    It's not that hard to remove and then replace a toilet IF you can lift it (they're sort of heavy). Problem is, since the toilet was not shimmed so it was stable, the thing has been leaking into the floor, and your floor may need to be replaced. If you're lucky, this hasn't been going on too long, and if you reset the toilet so it doesn't leak and rock, the floor will dry out and still be sound. If it's been awhile, it will never be right until the floor is replaced.
  3. Sponsor

    Sponsor Paid Advertisement

  4. pestario76

    pestario76 New Member

    Mar 4, 2010
    Westville, Indiana
    ok.. YES I would get help lifting.. LOL.. (hopefully!) So I guess the next question is... how do I know if the floor needs replaced or if its just the toilet? And .. LOL.. do you have any suggestions for lighting a fire under my landlords butt if the floor does need replaced? i have phoned.. and sent letters.. no reply as of yet..( I hate to nag.. makes me nervous)
  5. alannaimee@charter.net

    alannaimee@charter.net New Member

    Jul 9, 2007
    Helicopter Pilot
    East TN
    Just a DIYer here, but a few things come to mind. Unlevel tile floor, loose flange bolts. I had one with the same prob, my tile floor is unlevel. The toilet is easy to remove to investigate.
    TURN OFF THE WATER at the valve near the back (to the right).
    Flush the toilet to drain the tank, then soak up the rest with towels or use a shop vac if you have one.
    Loosen the nuts on the flange bolts (one on either side). Disconnect the water line at the tank (have the towel ready some water seems to always come out of mine).
    The toilet will then lift off the flange (its heavy and don't forget the tank cover that is not connected).

    You should be able to clean off the old wax ring and check it all out. The flange (a piece that has slots for the bolts to hold the toilet down and connects to the soil pipe) shouldn't be broken or cracked. The subfloor should be sound, no sign of leaking.

    If all that looks good, I'm out of suggestions. Once the toilet is pulled, you probably should cap the drain stack (I usually use a plastic bag just to keep the gases/ smell to a minimum although you can be rready to go back together in 30 mins or so). You'll also need a wax ring to reinstall the toilet ($1 or so at the boxes)

    The pros should be along shortly.

    Good luck,
  6. Gary Swart

    Gary Swart In the Trades

    Sep 1, 2004
    Yakima WA
    You mentioned a "landlord". This obviously indicates you are renting. This problem is the landlord's. He is required to maintain the plumbing and electrical. It is very rare that a renter is permitted to repair these problems. I'm not sure to whom you can report this if he balks at immediately getting this dealt with, but there are ways to force him if necessary.
Similar Threads: Tilted toilet
Forum Title Date
Toilet Forum discussions Need fix for a low, rusted, and slightly tilted closet flange Nov 9, 2007
Toilet Forum discussions Tilted cast iron pipe question! regarding flange Nov 20, 2006
Toilet Forum discussions Issue with upstairs toilets in 2 story house - intermittant flushing problems. Yesterday at 5:54 PM
Toilet Forum discussions Replacing toilet drain Yesterday at 1:36 PM
Toilet Forum discussions Sewage smell from toilet and difficult landlord Yesterday at 9:23 AM

Share This Page