UPDATE: Apparently the Expansion Tank Fairy came last night. I just went through the steps again. Closed the source valve, closed the water heater valve, bled off the water pressure. Checked the tank pressure, and it was about 20 psi. I serviced it up to 70 psi which I have the PRV set at. Checked the tank pressure and it's now 70-ish. Opened all the valves and water pressure and tank pressure are 70 psi +/-.
I don't know what to say. I think I'm done. lol
I don't know what to say. I think I'm done. lol