OL
New Member
Hello - I think I will need to replace a couple older (50 year) wall hung toilets in my house. Wondering whether there were any updated opinions on what seem to be the two main options- Gerber Maxwell and American Standard Glenwall. Is there a clear preference of one over another? Or is one better for some applications? (Am I missing another choice?)
I understand from reading reviews here that the AS Glenwall may have a stronger (if paper-shredding) flush, but that quality control is (or was) a problem - with cracked tanks, etc. Still true? And is that the case with the Gerber Maxwell as well? The Gerber Maxwell seems to be a slightly smaller option (27"depth, 17.25"wide, vs 29.5"depth & 19.5" wide for the AS Glenwall), which may fit better in my tight space, but I think either could work. Neither of these are cheap options, esp. with freight shipping, and I may have to order online (I am in upstate NY), so I'm trying to do my research.
Thanks in advance for any thoughts.
I understand from reading reviews here that the AS Glenwall may have a stronger (if paper-shredding) flush, but that quality control is (or was) a problem - with cracked tanks, etc. Still true? And is that the case with the Gerber Maxwell as well? The Gerber Maxwell seems to be a slightly smaller option (27"depth, 17.25"wide, vs 29.5"depth & 19.5" wide for the AS Glenwall), which may fit better in my tight space, but I think either could work. Neither of these are cheap options, esp. with freight shipping, and I may have to order online (I am in upstate NY), so I'm trying to do my research.
Thanks in advance for any thoughts.