Help please to identify 10" or 12" replacement toilet

Discussion in 'Toilet Forum discussions' started by LadyLee, May 24, 2012.

  1. LadyLee

    LadyLee New Member

    May 24, 2012
    I am confused!!! My son will install two new higher toilets for me but I'm not sure which to purchase. The master bathroom toilet is a Mansfield and the tank says A71 Feb 23, 2010 and it measures 12" from wall to bolt. So, that's a no-brainer I believe?

    Now the 2nd bathroom toilet tank is also a Mansfield and inside the tank it is stamped Mansfield 160. Here is the problem. This toilet from drywall (minus baseboard) to bolt has a 11½" measurement and the back of the tank is REALLY close to the wall.

    The question is whether to buy a 10" or a 12" toilet. I am thinking to replace both of these Mansfields with the ADA height AS Champion 4 Model 2586.

    I appreciate all the help I can get before I make the wrong purchase.

    Yes, the two Mansfields I am replacing are quite new and it's a shame just to toss them out in the end. But here's why - I am a senior and I purchased a condo all set for handicapped access but they installed regular low toilets. I want to move 'up' and this is going to be a treat for me.

    Thank you, Donna
  2. Terry

    Terry Administrator Staff Member

    Aug 17, 2004
    Bothell, Washington
    11.5" works with the newer 12" bowls.
    Get a 12" ADA or comfort height bowl.
  3. Sponsor

    Sponsor Paid Advertisement

  4. wjcandee

    wjcandee Wise One

    Apr 27, 2012
    New York, NY
    I'm no pro, but I can help a little. First, let me say that I have been amazingly-pleased with the Toto Drake toilets (and the more-expensive Toto Carlyle toilet) that I just installed in our home. The flush is reliable and amazing, and the toilets are stylish and well-made.

    I can tell you from actual personal experience installing these toilets that the Drake (just to be clear, not the Drake II, the plain ol' Drake: CST744) will fit a rough-in as small as 11" (and Terry indicates that the real bottom-line minimum is actually 10 7/8"), and look nice doing it. You would have no difficulty at all from the Drake based on the rough-in you mention. You can have the ADA-height CST744SL (the L is the ADA-height model: 16.5" bowl height like your AS, plus an inch for the recommended seat), for the same money as Home Depot would be charging you for the model you are looking at. Look at the Drakes on Terry's Toilet Reviews (click above in the green box), and see what you think. If you want the 1.6 gallons-per-flush (gpf) model, you would order the CST744SL, if you want the "watersense" 1.28 gpf model, you would order the CST744EL. (E for "eco", L for "ADA height"). The base (and price) on both is the same, just tank and tank guts are different.

    The Drake II is about $20 more than the model you are looking at, and seems to get great reviews and has a nice modern look. It comes with Sanagloss, Double Cyclone Flush, and at the Universal Height (17.25" seat height). So it seems like a great value. However, Terry says that it for sure requires a minimum 11.5" rough-in. So you would be right at the absolute minimum for the kind of installation a son of typical skills could do himself.

    Of course, in fairness, the AS comes with a seat and the wax ring and closet bolts, while the Toto toilets do not. I like this because I can choose my own seats, and there are some I really like, and it's no big deal for me to go get a wax ring, new supply hose, closet bolts and caulk down at the local hardware store. However, it does add a few dollars per toilet to the apples-to-apples comparison.

    Hope this helps.
    Last edited by a moderator: Jun 26, 2012
  5. jadnashua

    jadnashua Retired Defense Industry Engineer xxx

    Sep 2, 2004
    Retired Systems engineer for defense industry.
    New England
    If you get one that is made well, the AS is a decent toilet...their defect rate seems to be higher than some, and definately higher than Totos.
Similar Threads: Help please
Forum Title Date
Toilet Forum discussions Please Help - Toilet Bowl Only Fills Half Way Jul 12, 2017
Toilet Forum discussions BOILING HOT WATER from my cold water tap!! Help Please. Jul 2, 2017
Toilet Forum discussions Please help! Toilet is frustrating me! Dec 27, 2016
Toilet Forum discussions PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE HELP!!! My toliet tank apparently grew and NO LONGER FITS!! Nov 10, 2016
Toilet Forum discussions Very old American Standard Cadet Model F4049-16- need some help please Sep 25, 2016

Share This Page