Anyone with 1st-hand Kohler Class Five Flushing Experience?

Discussion in 'Toilet Forum discussions' started by MikeLane, Nov 1, 2005.

  1. MikeLane

    MikeLane New Member

    Nov 1, 2005
    My wife and I are remodeling three bathrooms and a kitchen at the same time and was interested in using the Kohler Memoirs Suite in the guest bathroom. I would like to know if anyone has any first-hand (or butt) experience with the new one-piece Memoirs Comfort Height toilet with Stately design. I have limited experience with one and two-piece toilets because my previous apartment had those high-pressure flush valves (have no idea what they're called) that I will miss. Conventional wisdom tells me to forget about one-piece and after reading most of the posts in this forum I didn't see too much love (pardon the pun) out there for Kohler of American Standard toilets but thought I would check anyway since this is new technology and it's going in the guest bathroom.

    All thoughts and comments appreciated, I guess flames as well.

  2. Terry

    Terry Administrator Staff Member

    Aug 17, 2004
    Bothell, Washington
    The first one with the Kohler class 5 flush was the Cimarron.

    Consumer comments are there.

    When I used the Cimarron, I noticed the lack of bowl wash at the back.
    It works better than their 2" flush valve models, but not as well at the better brands that use a 3" flush valve.
  3. Sponsor

    Sponsor Paid Advertisement

  4. MikeLane

    MikeLane New Member

    Nov 1, 2005
    Thanks Terry for your quick reply. Any idea if all Kohler Class Five flushing toilets have the same bowl design and lack of bowl wash at the back or is this limited to the Cimarron model?

    What one and two-piece "better brands" with a 3" flush valve should I consider if we were thinking of NOT matching the toilet to the sink. BTW, I'm more interested in no plugging and better bowl wash than noise and style. Since this is a guest bathroom I thought it would be ok to sacrafice looks (makes my wife a happy camper) for funtionality. Does that make any sense?

  5. achutch

    achutch Member

    Oct 20, 2005
    Last year, I installed a Kohler Cimarron with Class Five flushing action in my second floor bathroom, which replaced a series of toilets (some of them 5-gallons per flush) each of which had deficiencies that required a second or sometimes three flushes before the water came back clean.
    The Cimarron flushed solids fine most of the time (it plugged once requiring a plunger). But, true to the comments on this site, the bowl rinse was poor.
    Because of the rinsing problem, I replaced the Cimarron with the Toto Drake, and am so far very happy with it (the best toilet in that bathroom since my home was built almost 20 years ago); no clogs, no "spit-ups" and a good rinse, almost equal to my 1936 "Standard" MODERNUS in my first floor half-bath.
    Unless Kohler has addressed the rinsing issue over the past year, I would consider something else.

Similar Threads: Anyone 1st-hand
Forum Title Date
Toilet Forum discussions Does anyone make a fill valve that you can use the chlorine pucks with? Oct 20, 2016
Toilet Forum discussions Anyone have a Toto THU223#CP part hanging around? Oct 18, 2016
Toilet Forum discussions Does anyone know of any source for McPherson Upflush toilet parts May 8, 2016
Toilet Forum discussions Anyone know the likely age of my toilet? Jun 28, 2015
Toilet Forum discussions Anyone have a good or bad experience with GSI, sold by Nameek's? May 2, 2015

Share This Page