Replaceing Oil Boiler and Electric Hot Water Heater w/ Gas

Discussion in 'Boiler Forum' started by bjferri, Sep 12, 2011.

  1. bjferri

    bjferri DoD Army

    Jun 5, 2007
    Department of the Army Civilian (DAC)
    I need help making this decision please…looking at it from a long term economical stand point.

    A) Do I purchase a hot water heater and boiler and vent through the chimney? If so, I’ll need to spend $2000 for a stainless steel liner to re-line the chimney.

    B) Or, do I spend a little more for high efficiency boiler and direct vent to outside and not use chimney?

    If I go with Option B, what do I do about the hot water heater? I was told I could use an indirect water heater with the boiler…is this a good idea?

    Thanks in advance… any ideas would be helpful.
  2. Tom Sawyer

    Tom Sawyer In the Trades

    Nov 29, 2010
    Option B and the indirect.
  3. Sponsor

    Sponsor Paid Advertisement

  4. Dana

    Dana In the trades

    Jan 14, 2009
    What Tom said. By the time you factor in the cost of an SS flue liner it's cheaper to buy a condensing boiler.

    Depending on your actual heat load there's a middle-ground. Power drafted 85-88% AFUE cast iron boilers exist (some sealed-combustion, others not), and may be a suitable alternative. But the smallest of them are 2-plate units with ~40-45KBTU of output. If your heat load is well under 30KBTU at design condition you'll get much better peformance out of the smallest-in-class modulating-condensing boilers. And if you can't park the thing next to a wall you'll be into some fairly expensive stainless steel side-venting, if local code prevents you from using B-vent even as a chimney liner. (Some places will allow B-vent as a liner for gas boilers, but not for oil.)

    By the time it's said & done, with any federal/state/local subsidy for going with a mod-con it may be cheaper & better up front to go with the higher efficiency. Just be sure to buy the smallest unit that actually meets your design-day heat load- a 3-4x oversized mod-con will cost more up front and likely short-cycle itself into an early grave.

    Be sure to seal up the unused flue, otherwise it'll be driving air-infiltration 24/365. With a sealed-combustion mod-con you can make the place super-tight without fear of backdrafting issues, and doing so will lower your heating AND air conditioning bills.
Similar Threads: Replaceing Boiler
Forum Title Date
Boiler Forum Increasing boiler pressure, cracked exchanger? Jun 15, 2017
Boiler Forum Hybrid Boiler System - Pressure Relief Valve May 31, 2017
Boiler Forum Chimney vs. Direct Vent vs Power Vent for oil boiler May 26, 2017
Boiler Forum Boiler Overheating, Pressure Release Valve Discharging, Pipes Knocking Apr 24, 2017
Boiler Forum Question about hot water boiler, baseboard always hot Apr 17, 2017

Share This Page