1957 Eljer Toilet Help

[KatieH]

(I tried posting yesterday but can't find any evidence it worked - so I'm sorry if this is appearing twice.)

We've inherited the house I grew up in - has three Eljer toilets, one of which has been dry for about four years due to a leak. I want to fix it for various reasons (and I don't want to replace it with a new one unless I have to), but discovered after disassembling that the Korky universal 2" kit work.

I want to replace everything on it from the wax ring up to the gasket between the tank and the bowl to the fill valve to the flapper. When I started, I saw my dad had replaced the fill valve. The flapper was missing so I'm not sure what I'm looking for.

I looked at plumbing supply.org, but I had a hard time figuring out what toilet it is. (Pictures below) I thought maybe a Hygeian or a 5140, but the numbers inside the tank say 44 and then maybe 3, and the lid says 275 4. Any help with figuring out what replacement parts I need? Once I know what I need, I'm pretty good at finding it.

Thank you,
Katie

 

[Peterson]

You have an Eljer Duplex toilet. These were very popular in the 1950's and phased out around 1959 when the Emblem model replaced it. Parts are available.

You need a fill valve (fluidmaster or korky), metal handle (not plastic), and tank ball with guide wires. The tank ball sits right on porcelain bottom of the tank and the guide wires go through the brass bracket screwed into the tank.

It takes an Eljer tank to bowl gasket that will fit an Emblem model toilet. It's very flat rubber gasket.

Go on Youtube and type in Eljer Duplex and you will see how to assemble these things.

Cheers!

 

[Sponsor]

 

[Reach4]

If it does not have a lot of sentimental value, consider replacing the toilet.

 

[KatieH]

You have an Eljer Duplex toilet. These were very popular in the 1950's and phased out around 1959 when the Emblem model replaced it. Parts are available.

You need a fill valve (fluidmaster or korky), metal handle (not plastic), and tank ball with guide wires. The tank ball sits right on porcelain bottom of the tank and the guide wires go through the brass bracket screwed into the tank.

It takes an Eljer tank to bowl gasket that will fit an Emblem model toilet. It's very flat rubber gasket.

Go on Youtube and type in Eljer Duplex and you will see how to assemble these things.

Cheers!

Thank you so much! Exactly what help I needed. ☺️

 

[Rick Carone]

It sounds like you’re working with an older Eljer toilet, and finding the right parts can be tricky. The numbers inside the tank and lid (like 44 and 275 4) can help identify the exact model. Try reaching out to Eljer support or taking those numbers to a plumbing store—they might have guides to match the parts. In the meantime, you could use a universal flapper and fill valve as a temporary fix until you’re sure what you need.

 

[Fitter30]

Check this company
www.plumbingsupply.com/eljer-toilets.html

 

[KatieH]

Check this company
www.plumbingsupply.com/eljer-toilets.html

Thank you. I did say I was looking at them. Just called it .org instead of .com for some reason.

 

[Fitter30]

Thank you. I did say I was looking at them. Just called it .org instead of .com for some reason.

Contact them might help with the numbers that u have they have a form to fill out. Just click on the three bar left of their name.