Opinions on two different American Standard Garbage disposals from Costco

[Murphysf]

Hello

I need to replace my garbage disposal and saw these at Costco

Online only:
Item 1412931
Model ASD-125-SL made by Joneca ? $69.99 for the month of July

https://www.costco.com/american-standard-slim-line-125hp-food-waste-disposer.product.100692318.html

Online and In Store
Item 1878939

Model 10-US-ASD-825-SL or ASD-825-SL made by ? $99 in store or $109 online

https://www.costco.com/american-standard-slim-line-125hp-garbage-disposer.product.4000319673.html

Do any of you have any experience with these? Looking for opinions

 

[Master Plumber Mark]

You are wise to get an ISE V disposal from any hardware store.... At HD it was 129.00
The ISE has a much better heavy duty SS metal flange that connects extra solid to the sink , and the
disposal is more solid and normally never vibrates loose... The flange is good forever too...

Maybe the 69dollar bargain uses the same kind of locking flange that
the ISE uses but odds are its just a peice of junk .... with some kind of crappy solid
plastic flange that you can never get tight enough and gives you leaking fits
down the road.....

 

[Sponsor]

 

[Breplum]

They all use SS flange, ISE type of locking. I have put in plenty of the cheaper, skinnier A.S. models from Costco and they are fine with no callbacks.
Always use plenty (excessive) of water when running and all will be good. Get an OXO basket strainer and compost bin most everything. Never put high volume of fibrous material down the drain.

 

[Master Plumber Mark]

They all use SS flange, ISE type of locking. I have put in plenty of the cheaper, skinnier A.S. models from Costco and they are fine with no callbacks.
Always use plenty (excessive) of water when running and all will be good. Get an OXO basket strainer and compost bin most everything. Never put high volume of fibrous material down the drain.

Their are some really shitty brands out there with plastic flanges..... I remember the Swirl-away brand....
and many other cheap ass brands... that I told the customer to just take back...

That SS flange is very popular and is on the Emerson brand and others

But I would rather go with the ISE