Critique/improve my idea for a pump house please...

Users who are viewing this thread

cdherman

Member
Messages
54
Reaction score
10
Points
8
Location
Rural Western Kansas
I'm back. Spring will arrive in a month or two and with it will be better weather to address the well issues at my brother/parents farm in western KS.

The current messed up situation is a 12" well with modern sanitary cap, about 20" above grade, with the pressure switch and a tiny pressure tank jerry rigged into the 12" casing. There were eternal problems with freezing, short cycling, pump drawing down and sucking air etc. We have convinced ourselves that the well fundamentally has enough water in it, but a more spacious enclosure for a cycle stop sensor, larger pressure tank exterior to the casing all are needed. (we are also going to install a cycle stop valve and a flow inducer).

Here is my current plan for a frost free or nearly frost free pump house.

We dig down about 7'. Easy enough in that part of the world -- the soil there is blown in glacial loess and goes 40' until it hits limestone bedrock, on which there is a shallow but moving stream of water. Frost line there is historically around 3', less these days.

Lay in a level layer of coarse crushed rock around 10". This is to allow for potential drainage of leaks and to allow earth warmth to rise.

Build a wall on the crushed rock -- no footing since the wall will not support weight, just itself. Plan to use insulated block concrete forms, like the pic.

install.jpg


I was thinking about 8' x 8' outside dimensions. The bocks pretty much force you into 2' increments and the inside dimension of 6x6 would be more like 4'x4'. A little tight. THIS IS AN AREA I AM REALLY LOOKING FOR INPUT. MAYBE 6X6 IS FINE??? 6x6 would make for a smaller, lighter roof as well.

Plan is to bring the blocks up to about 6" BELOW the top of the well. Although there are no codes and no inspections there, I want to ensure that should the pit ever flood, no water enters the sanitary well -- it would flow over the sides of the walls first.

We would pour the walls, let cure obviously, probably protect on the outside with a layer of cement board (you can screw it to the high density foam insulations, and then grade the surrounding area to about 6' below the top of the walls. This would get a nice deep insulated pit.

Then I plan to construct a hip style roof cap. I've done a fair amount of wood working and such -- I have done this before where you calculate the tricky compound angles and cut 4 triangles. The cuts are compound. Done right it all fits like a puzzle together and you glue and screw. No rafters needed, since the pyramidal form is very strong, and reasonably light. Light metal roofing on outside, and 4" (or thicker if I can find it) high density foam insulation on the underside, with the joints foamed in for good tight seal.

That cap will hopefully weight enough that it won't fly off and be light enough that a decent person can tip it up and off. Being able to take the top off completely makes pulling the pump down the road so much easier. If the cap ends up too heavy, this is a big farm -- we can affix a lifting loop on the roof and lift it off with a loader.

Current electrical supply is 240v, 2 hot and ground. Sadly they did not bury three wires. I would like to put a "greenhouse plug" in the well house and a heater so that if the temp drops too low, it has a backup heat source. My family has been running the 120v heat bulb for years by wiring it one leg of 240v and the neutral is the ground wire. Not correct, but worked. I don't think the breaker back at the pole would like that with a 1500w heater however. I will try and find a 240v greenhouse plug and 240v heater.

I read somewhere about the crushed rock -- they were saying NOT to put a concrete floor or pad into a pit, as it would impede the rising warmth. Oh, and the risk of water coming in below the walls is ZERO. This is very dry country. Large rains do occur, but properly graded no water ever enters basements. My parents house has a proper sump sump -- its ran once in 45 years. When a pipe broke.
 

Reach4

Well-Known Member
Messages
41,046
Reaction score
4,918
Points
113
Location
IL
They make big pressure tanks made to be buried. Then you need to get the pressure switch not to freeze. They used to make pressure switches for that, and maybe they still do.
 

Valveman

Cary Austin
Staff member
Messages
15,474
Reaction score
1,523
Points
113
Location
Lubbock, Texas
Website
cyclestopvalves.com
Sounds like a good plan, but a very elaborate well house. The best way to keep a pump system from freezing is to keep all the pipes below the frost line. A pitless adapter in the well makes the outlet pipe come through the casing below the frost line. The little pressure tank used with a Cycle Stop Valve can then be installed inside the house where it is warm. There is also a Cycle Stop Valve that will fit in the well below the pitless, so the water line can be tapped into anywhere on the way to the pressure tank/switch. There are also pressure tanks that can fit in the well above the CSV and below the pitless. Even the best well house can let the pump system freeze if the power is off for any length of time. With a pitless, nothing freezes no matter what.

PK1A Sub Pitless House.jpg
PK125 With Hydrant.png
 

cdherman

Member
Messages
54
Reaction score
10
Points
8
Location
Rural Western Kansas
Sounds like a good plan, but a very elaborate well house. The best way to keep a pump system from freezing is to keep all the pipes below the frost line. A pitless adapter in the well makes the outlet pipe come through the casing below the frost line. The little pressure tank used with a Cycle Stop Valve can then be installed inside the house where it is warm. There is also a Cycle Stop Valve that will fit in the well below the pitless, so the water line can be tapped into anywhere on the way to the pressure tank/switch. There are also pressure tanks that can fit in the well above the CSV and below the pitless. Even the best well house can let the pump system freeze if the power is off for any length of time. With a pitless, nothing freezes no matter what.

View attachment 103799View attachment 103800

So how far away can a pressure tank be in the house? No pressure tank in the pit sounds nice too. The well currently has a pitless setup with a hydrant right next to the well. How large a pressure tank can be placed in the house -- I assume as large as is desired? There is some interest in having a modest amount of water supply during power outages, thus part of the interest in a larger pressure tank. The house is over 100ft away and much of the rest of the water supply of the far connects to the lines going to the house. There are about 6 frost free hydrants in various locations.
 

Valveman

Cary Austin
Staff member
Messages
15,474
Reaction score
1,523
Points
113
Location
Lubbock, Texas
Website
cyclestopvalves.com
The pressure switch and pressure tank must be close together. So, if power comes from the house to the well it is easy to put the pressure switch/tank at the house. As long as there are no check valves above ground, and the pipe to the tank is adequate, not restricted, the tank/switch can be a mile away and anywhere in the house close to the power.

With a CSVS125 in the well before the pitless, any hydrants or tees off the mainline going to the house are controlled, and most likely a 4.5 gallon size tank is all you need. With a CSV the water goes right past the tank, making the tank a moot point for everything except the icemaker and washing a toothbrush. The 4.5 gallon size tank holds 1 gallon of water to take care of those little things.

Even a huge 80 gallon size tank only holds 20 gallons of water. You also cannot count on there being any water in that huge tank when the power goes off. With a 40/60 switch the tank is full at 60 and empty at 40 PSI. It is simply luck if the tank happen to be full when the power goes off. The power went off so you are already having bad luck. What makes you thing the gauge on the tank reads any higher than 41 PSI, meaning it has 1 gallon to use while the power is off. Best to keep a 5 gallon jug of water in a closet and a generator to run the pump for long term power outages. Pressure tanks are a false sense of security for having water. As long as the Cycle Stop Valve is installed before the first hydrant or tee, you can have as many taps coming off the mainline and anywhere you want them.

CSVS125 in well with 20 gallon tank, hydrant and houses.jpg
 

Reach4

Well-Known Member
Messages
41,046
Reaction score
4,918
Points
113
Location
IL
While the amount of water in a pressure tank when the electricity goes off is probabilistic, if you start up a portable generator to run the pump during an outage, that would fill the pressure tank. So you could go for some amount of water use before having to start the generator again.

If running a well pump with a generator, you have to derate it some, with a conventional 2-wire pump needing more compensation.

But that indoor pressure tank and switch certainly let you forgo the well house.
 

Bannerman

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,286
Reaction score
973
Points
113
Location
Ontario, Canada
most likely a 4.5 gallon size tank is all you need. ... The 4.5 gallon size tank holds 1 gallon of water
As the CSV will prevent the pump from cycling, a large pressure tank is not required.

A further benefit of a CSV equipped with a small 4.5 gallon pressure tank, only 1-gallon water use will cause the pump to become rapidly activated, which will then cause the CSV to supply constant 50 psi pressure to fixtures, for the entire time more than 1 gpm continues to be utilized. If equipped with a 10-gallon pressure tank, then up to ~2.5 gallons use will cause the pump to become activated.

When a larger than recommended pressure tank is utilized such as an 80-gallon tank, then up to 20 gallons will need to be consumed before the pump becomes activated. This results in the pressure of the initial 20 gallons to continually decline from 60 to 40 psi before the pump become activated, which results in an unnecessary extended delay before you will enjoy constant 50 psi or higher pressure from fixtures.
 
Top
Hey, wait a minute.

This is awkward, but...

It looks like you're using an ad blocker. We get it, but (1) terrylove.com can't live without ads, and (2) ad blockers can cause issues with videos and comments. If you'd like to support the site, please allow ads.

If any particular ad is your REASON for blocking ads, please let us know. We might be able to do something about it. Thanks.
I've Disabled AdBlock    No Thanks