My daughter and son-in-law bought an old house in the city. There was renovations done to it prior to them moving, including kitchen and the attic turned into a master suite. After being in the house a while, they noticed a sewer type smell. First thing we did was put a cover over the sump pump pit. That cut down on odors, but sewer smell continued intermittently. The house has a partial basement with crawl space. We found an open metal pipe coming up out of the crawl space and cemented it shut and put a cap on it. Still had the periodic smell. All the sinks had s-traps, so we changed to ptraps with horizontal runs and AAVs before running back down in basement. Seemed to work, but smell came back. Today, we pulled the washer and dryer out because it seemed to possibly occur after laundry. It has a trap. We resorted to a smoke test and found smoke billowed out of a horizontal hole running from underneath the basement steps back under the crawl space. No smoke anywhere else. Good flow out the roof vent. Where the smoke came out, there was no pipe, but the ground is a perfect circle, like a pipe had been pulled out. There is no way that pipe is tied into the existing plumbing inside the house. What I am guessing is there was a sewer line running from that area out to the sewer in the street and it was never capped off when they replaced it with a new main line about 15 feet away. I suspect that the smell is coming up the old line into the crawl space and then exiting through that hole. I suspect the vertical pipe we capped is hooked to that same run. My question is, how do we identify where that old line is coming into the house? It will be easier to dig it up outside then attempt to dig it in the crawl space. There is just not much room. Any advice is appreciated