Sound mitigation.

Discussion in 'Remodel Forum & Blog' started by Rughead, Jun 8, 2010.

  1. Rughead

    Rughead New Member

    Messages:
    48
    Location:
    Scarsdale, NY
    Hi guys. Been with you all for over a decade and have used your sage advice often in every sector, to the best possible results. (Thanks Dana for the rat slab and the under the Florida room advice.) I now find myself in Islamabad at work for the next 18 months, then I retire at 62 (finally). Moving into what they call here an "annex", which is simply a 2 bed, 3 bath (??), 2 story house with a nice roof terrace. Stay with me here, the power supply is iffy at best all day and nite. Shedding is the norm. So I have, courtesy of the UN, a nice water cooled 10 KVA (net) generator for my house. More power than I need, so I'll also supply my landlord/neighbor and he'll readily agree to that. Auro switchover installation to be done by the UN certified electrical engineer company. (Ha, bloody ha :rolleyes:.)

    The problem is the noise of the genset. I'll put it as far from the house as possible, say 60 ft., but from experience I know that it's a noisy bugger. My idea is to surround it with a double bamboo walled cage insulated with paper mache egg cartons. Cost effective and sound reducing effective. Sound travels in a direct line and if it is disturbed, it fragments. I'd like to do both. Any better ideas? Cheers, Rug.
  2. Dana

    Dana In the trades

    Messages:
    3,021
    Location:
    01609
    Sound doesn't travel in a straight line- it's a pressure wave, and some amount will bleed around the edges of an incomplete enclosure no matter how absorptive or reflective it is. Thing of a water wave propogating orthogonal to a jetty- the brunt of the wave on the sheltered is attenuated the further in you get from the end, but there's still a signficant amount of wave near the tip. The further to the sheltered side you get, the less difference there is between being 5' from the tip vs. 50', but the whole wave is much attenuated. For a wall to do the job it has to be pretty tall, and must resist direct transmission of the wave through the wall.

    The amount of direct transmission through the wall is a function of how much of the energy in the wave that it can dissipate as heat (mechanical absorption), and how much it can reflect away. A bamboo & low-density paper wall will reflect a little, and absorb a little. Making it more rigid on the side facing the source makes it reflect more, and adding density to the wall will limit how how much the side facing you can move. If there's a way to grind up the egg cartons so that they pack more densely you'll get both increased mechanical absorption and an increased mass. Building an earthen wall probably works even better, but may be a lot more work. If it's open at the top you'll still get the edge-bleed, so unless you're going to enclose it completely it may not be worth building a more massive & permanent structure just for sound-abatement. If it can be reasonably installed in a pit deep enough that it's all below-grade, with no line-of-sight from the edge of the pit to your apartment the earth can be your primary acoustic shell, and an absorptive wall above grade wall around the pit can take it down another few dB without being 15' tall

    Mounting the generator on vibe-absorbing materials will cut down on the low-frequency stuff, much of which will be ground-transmitted. There may be ways of better muffling the exhaust as well, but whether & how that's done would be specific to the equipment.
Similar Threads: Sound mitigation
Forum Title Date
Remodel Forum & Blog Sound retarding "reduction" for a wall. Jun 3, 2013
Remodel Forum & Blog Plumbing Quote for Master Bath Remodel - does this sound reasonable? (pic's inside) Jan 9, 2013
Remodel Forum & Blog Soundproofing around a shower? Feb 20, 2012
Remodel Forum & Blog soundproof walls Jan 18, 2011
Remodel Forum & Blog hollow sound under self level compound Mar 19, 2010

Share This Page