SteV8e
Mechanical Engineer
I recently experienced smelly water (suddenly) from an old (15+ years) Montgomery Wards water heater. A plumber quoted me $250 to replace the magnesium rod or $600 to replace the whole water heater. I had him install a new GE 50 gallon electric water heater. Three weeks later the smell is back. I live in a Minneapolis suburb that has well water. The plumber that installed the heater does not know what to do.
I have heard from other plumbers that I have contacted, that it could be solved by replacing the rod with an aluminum rod, by removing the rod and not replacing it, or by installing a water filter on the supply. I have also heard that replacing or removing the rod will void the warranty (12 years).
I don't know what to do. I have the new water heater and I have stinky hot water again. Please help.
I have heard from other plumbers that I have contacted, that it could be solved by replacing the rod with an aluminum rod, by removing the rod and not replacing it, or by installing a water filter on the supply. I have also heard that replacing or removing the rod will void the warranty (12 years).
I don't know what to do. I have the new water heater and I have stinky hot water again. Please help.